Posts Tagged Bullying

Stop Bullying My Child

With the growing incidence of bullying at school and related student suicides, many people are concerned that there is not enough teeth in the law to protect students from this conduct.  While efforts have been made in Michigan to pass anti-bullying laws, there has been much resistance to that in the Legislature.

             One frustrated family decided to take a different path when their son continued to experience bullying throughout middle school and into high school.   The bullying affected his grades and his self-esteem.  He was sexually assaulted at school.  He was certified as “emotionally impaired” and offered special education services. While the school did some investigation and made some attempt to intervene, it was not enough to protect this students.  The parents finally decided to sue in federal court Title IX, the federal statute that provides that no student may “be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any educational program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance….” 20 U.S.C. § 1681.   The United States Supreme Court developed a three part test for Title IX cases in Davis v. Monroe County Board of Education, 526 U.S. 629, 119 S.Ct. 1661, 143 L.Ed.2d 839 (1999), and the Sixth Circuit adopted that test in Vance v. Spencer County Public School District, 231 F.3d 253 (6th Cir.2000).   In the Daviscase, the Supreme Court held that IX may support a claim for student-on-student sexual harassment when the plaintiff can demonstrate the following elements:

          (1)        the sexual harassment was so severe, pervasive, and objectively offensive that it could be said to deprive the plaintiff of access to the educational opportunities or benefits provided by the school;

           (2)        the funding recipient had actual knowledge of the sexual harassment, and

           (3)        the funding recipient was deliberately indifferent to the harassment.

             In Patterson v. Hudson Area Schools, 551 F3d 438 (Mich. 2009), the Sixth Circuit held that the student had offered sufficient evidence to avoid dismissal of the case, and the case was remanded for a jury trial.  While school had made some effort to intervene, support the student, and enforce its anti-sexual harassment policy, the court held that this was not enough to avoid the claim that it had been, in fact, “deliberately indifferent to the harassment.”

             It is a pity when parents are forced into federal court to protect their children from bullying.   Michigan should criminalize this behavior.  It should not just be treated as a civil matter, especially when the bullying itself is often a crime and the bullying often leads to academic failure, social stigma, and often suicide.

 

, ,

No Comments

What bullying isn?t and what to do when it happens

Bullying is a word that’s wrapped in emotion.

For many people bullying is associated with bad childhood memories. It’s been estimated that around 40% of people have experienced some type of bullying in the past.

The ghosts from the past are never far away for parents and can sometimes influence the way we react to current circumstances, including when our own children experience difficulties in their relationships inside or outside school.

Bullying is an insidious behaviour that transgresses children’s natural right to feel safe and secure. It can adversely affect their learning, emotional well-being, further peer relations and their sense of self.

Bullying takes many forms and guises including physical and emotional abuse, intimidation, harassment and exclusion.

It now has a well-publicised cyber-dimension which has moved the goalposts for many kids. In the past children could escape bullying behaviours they may have experienced by being at home. Cyber-bullying now means that kids can’t escape the bully like they once could.

Bullying is not the domain of one gender. Girls bully just as much as boys but they do it in less physical ways. While boys use physical intimidation or verbal abuse to wield power, girls are more likely to use exclusion or verbal sarcasm to assert themselves.

Bullying should not be confused with teasing, rejection, random acts of violence or physicality and conflict.  While children will often tease or fight, this bickering should not be confused with bullying.

Bullying is about lack of power as one person is powerless to stop the teasing or physical abuse. Bullying is the selective, uninvited, repetitive oppression of one person by another person or group. It should not be tolerated or practised by the adults who inhabit their world.

If you think your child is being bullied then proceed with care as children often don’t want to admit that they are on the receiving end of bullying. Some kids keep it to their chest so it helps to be on lookout for warning signs such as: items being stolen, changing the route to school and withdrawal from usual activities. (There is heaps more information in the bullying chapter of One Step Ahead).

If your child is being bullied:

Listen to their story: Children who are bullied need someone to believe their story. Take them seriously and avoid dismissing complaints as tell-tale. Use common sense to differentiate between bullying and more random, non-selective ant-social acts. Kids can be nasty too each other, yet nastiness doesn’t always constitute bullying.
Deal with their feelings: A child who is bullied probably feels scared, angry and sad. Boys are more likely to display anger and girls claim they feel sad. The degree of emotional intensity is an indicator of the amount of bullying. Recognise and validate their emotions. Let them, talk about how they think (remember boys respond better to ‘think’ language) and feel. It’s normal to feel sad, scared or just plain confused. Get the facts: Get a clear picture of what happens, including who is involved, the frequency and what happens prior to any bullying. Get your child to be as specific as possible by asking good questions. An accurate picture will help you determine your next course of action. Give them coping skills: With a clear picture you can start giving your child some help about how he or she may deal with bullying including; using avoidance strategies, being more assertive and changing body poor language. Get the school involved: Bullying is best handled when parents and teachers are involved. Some parents tell me that schools can be reluctant to become involved. From my experience, schools take bullying very seriously and go to great lengths to support and empower those on the receiving ends and look for ways to change the behaviour of bullies. Approach your school through the appropriate channels, make yourself aware of your schools’ anti-bullying procedures and programs, and be willing to work within these guidelines.
Help build your child’s support networks: Kids need a group of friends to support them when they experience bullying so look for practical ways to broaden friendships groups. Build their self-confidence: Provide children with systematic encouragement. Let them know through your words and treatment of them that they will get through this period.

It’s worth remembering that children who experience some form of bullying often come out stronger and more resourceful because they have experienced difficulties and they know they can defeat them.

(More information about dealing with bullying can be found in One Step Ahead – order here)

, ,

No Comments

Anti Bullying Programs: How Does Your Child’s School Rank?

There are scores of different anti-bully programs being run in schools throughout America and hundreds more competing for a share of the market.  Which ones have the winning track record of proven results?

There certainly are lots to choose from.  Some states pass laws mandating a comprehensive framework of special training for teachers and administrators that dovetails with student awareness programs, detailed reporting procedures, and ’solution’ schedules that range from mediation to suspension.

Other schools outsource their anti-bully programs to ‘experts’. Again, there’s an incredible array of options.  The ranks include psychiatrists and psychologists, PhD’s, lawyers, martial artists, clergy members, former victims, activists for peace & love, and even extreme BMX stunt performers. There are individuals who’ll do a one day assembly, and organizations that specialize in comprehensive, multi-year, district wide contracts.

How do all of these stack up against each other?

First, let’s take a look at the public school system.  The embarrassing reality is that American students rank far below their peers in other developed countries – in benchmark areas such as science and mathematics, US children are in the bottom third.  Our nosedive to the bottom is accelerating, too.  Government employed teachers seem unable to impart the basics.  What possible hope is there that they can be trusted to successfully execute a complex, social design experiment?

Next, consider private schools.  Along with a better reputation for academic achievement, there’s an air of prestige, and a considerable tuition obligation.   Such institutions are understandably reluctant to admit there’s a bullying problem, as that would damage their perceived status.  And if there’ s no problem, there’s no need to fix it.

Lastly, we can take a look at the independent gurus.  For the most part, they’re undoubtedly good men and women with noble intentions. And they’re running businesses (it’s a very lucrative market).  Naturally, their curriculum are designed to appeal to committees, boards and administrators (who have the money) instead of the children (who have the problems).  Marketing is the foremost concern- effectiveness runs a distant second.

As a result,  the programs being installed have nothing to do with empirically effective methods, and everything to do with ‘feeling good’ and cashing in. Yes, free market capitalism is a wonderful thing, and making a profit on your products or services is a wonderful thing.  When you’re providing something of value.

Years of research and mountains of evidence demonstrate that school-based anti-bullying programs have one thing in common: a dismal and disappointing record.  Continuing to promote them is unscrupulous.

, , , , ,

No Comments

The War On Bullying

Bullying has always been a serious problem.  While its unclear if social cruelty has actually gotten worse in recent years or if we’re just more aware of it because of increased attention, the current ‘War on Bullying’ trending up in popularity.

You might suppose that with so many passionate advocates working to fix the problem that there would be some major headway.  Between the new laws, programs and policies, you  might guess that bullies are on the run.

Before we take a look at the record of school-based anti-bullying policies, let’s take examine the  D.A.R.E. program for a parallel example.

*          The anti-drug movement was at a flash point in the 80’s, the anti-bully movement has been gaining momentum and is a hot topic now
*          There was a wide base of political and popular support for any law or program that promised a solution (DARE seemed to fit the bill). Anti-bullying legislation and school programs make identical promises.
*         Both DARE and school-based anti-bully programs are created / presented by ‘experts’
*          Media attention helped create and intensify an anti-drug mania.  Similarly, news coverage of  multi-million dollar verdicts in anti-bully law suits, and the portrait of spree-killers rampaging through schools as ‘troubled, bullied outcasts’ helps to fuel the anti-bully campaign.

The DARE (Drug Abuse Resistance Education) program features ‘friendly police officers’ who warn young students about the dangers of illegal drugs, as well as tobacco and alcohol and is now taught in over 75% of US school districts.  Its preposterously simplistic philosophy (“just say no!”) and lame curriculum (scare tactics, positive mantras and student pledges) raised questions since from its inception in 1983. Today, numerous studies have provided hard statistical evidence that DARE is an abysmal failure; the program has zero impact on its graduates rate of drug usage as compared to peers. The data revealing DARE’s complete inadequacy is so overwhelming that the General Accounting Office, the Department of Education and the Surgeon General’s Office have all   labeled the program as a gargantuan flop.  (A stunningly expensive flop, too – its squandered over $200 billion!)

Back to the anti-bully programs infiltrating school systems across America and around the world.

Dr. David Smith, PhD, of the University of Ottawa, conducted a meta analysis of all available research studies regarding the effectiveness of whole-school anti-bullying programs.  His results, published in the School Psychology Review (2004 issue) are  clear:

*          14% of victim outcome reports showed a minor positive benefit
*          86% of victim outcome reports were negligible or negative
*          100% of self-reporting bully outcome reports demonstrated negligible / negative effects

In 2007, another meta analysis out of Texas A&M  International University reviewed school-based bully prevention and intervention programs and came to the conclusion that overall, they showed “little discernible effect.”

Vreeman and Carroll published a review of 26 school-based anti-bully programs in 2007 issue of the Achieves of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine.  Only 3 could point to consistent reduction in bullying.

Dr. Wendy Craig, author, researcher, speaker and professor of psychology at the prestigious Queen’s University in Canada, reports in her study that in 15% of schools with comprehensive anti-bullying problems  actually experienced the problems get worse.

There are several anti-bully programs that testify how fantastic they are, and claim to have the documentation to prove it.  Where does this evidence come from?  Not surprisingly, from the very same companies that produce and market those programs.  This kind of back patting self-assessment is a little shady, and might be viewed with the same wariness as a child who grades his own report card or employee who writes his own performance review.

Just like the avaricious politicians, hysterical crusaders and un-informed ‘feel-good’ supporters who continue to champion the DARE program in spite of its losing record, the anti-bully movement is happily marching into the same ocean.

No Comments

Do you think that cyber bullying should be against the law ?

I was watching the news the other day. And I heard that the parents of a girl who hung herself,
are going to sue some of the students at her school. What was this story about ? Well this
young lady, rest her soul, showed her naked pictures to some of the boys at her school. The
next thing you know, it was all over the place. Her pics were being sent to other cell phones
and computers around the area. She was so devastated, this young girl, and she killed herself
by hanging from her bed. Now. The parents want to sue the students at her school. Do you
think that this is right ? Should people be sued for something or insult that they said online to
another individual. Some may say, it was her that did that to herself. Some would say otherwise.
What do you think………….

, , , ,

9 Comments

anti- bullying video to much for grade 4 students? with out parental consent?

First let me say that I am on bord with the anti-bullying program. I think that this is a message that should be out there. It should not be sugar coated and children need to know the effects of bullying. Now that being said I was horrified to find out that yesterday with out my knowledge my my 9 year old sons school showed an animated video where a child was fed up with being bullied and in the end hung himself from the slide in the park at school. My question is this, Am I wrong in feeling that is A a bit too over the top for that age group? And B should we as parents not have been informed the school was going to show this video, so we could make the call on weather or not we felt our child was emotionally and mentally ready for this video?
I want to clarify that This is a city wide school program. We we informed that the school was going to be having talks and the children were going to be sighning an anti bullying contract.At no time were we informed that this video was to be presented to our children.

, , , , , , ,

9 Comments

Why doesn’t the school do more to prevent this bullying?

There’s a girl at my secondary school, she’s in the year below me and she was at the same primary school as me. She gets quite badly bullied it’s mostly verbal but I’ve sometimes come across some physical stuff.

The school doesn’t seem to ANYTHING about it though!!! And they DO know, it’s do obvious!! I’ve come across this girl in a couple of classrooms where the teacher let her stay behind and compose herself. I remember one time, in primary a group if girls in the same year as her, blamed her for something she had not done, it was made up! And when I told a reacher what had actually happened, she wouldn’t even look at me!! She just nodded and was like ‘riiiight’!
Both schools have an anti-policy and do BUGGER ALL!!

About 6 months ago, I skipped a couple of classes with this girl and another friend and teachers found us, and I thought something was finally going to happen but they lost intrest after a couple if days, NOTHING was dooone!! And then my parents told me to try and stay away from her!

I just don’t understand it!! Why doesn’t the school do more to prevent this kind if abuse from happpening?????

, , , , ,

2 Comments

Online bullying or teasing. Are people getting psychologically weaker?

Because it’s just so easy to be a seven foot, super good-looking, invincible jerk/bitch if you can hide yourself in the internet. I’ve heard of Japanese adults in their 30s descend into depression because of “online teasing”. Excuse my ignorance, as much as I’m a tough bastard now, I was even a tougher bastard in my 20s. I have been belted up in prison by four men at a time, but I still fought back with rage. So how does online teasing work? Simply turn the god damn computer off if you can’t take it, how about that?

Disclaimer: This question is not directed towards children or under 20s.

, , , , , ,

8 Comments

Online bullying, loneliness, I feel like really harming myself?? I’m 12?

ok well I’m 12 years old (I’ll be 13 october…) and I have asperger syndrome and i’m really lonely because im homeschooled and i have hardly any friends in real life. So I joined this site, there were 12 year olds to 20 year olds on it, it was a forum for fans of a show. i joined it, my art wasn’t very good so people threatened me.

I was really new to that site and i kept posting in the wrong areas and they had banned me. i made an account on deviantart and they found me, they made deviantart accounts to flame my art work that I had made. They made fun of my autisim, saying it was just an excuse for me being a retard, and they made threatening journals against me and they threatened to make a site against me.

I made my own sites, they raided them and posted images that traumatized me, I was young back then and I should of told my parents but I had death threats, threats against me, my mother and my family and they threatened to find me and kill me.

People spammed me and sent me more death threats, taunting me saying my artwork was **** after all the hard work I had done on it, they hacked my deviantart account, stole art with it and made a journal telling I was a retard. They made me look so bad, when a troll told me what a jewish person was and I didn’t know everyone intercepted me and called me a retard…i know I’m not a retard because my iq is in it’s 140’s, but when this happens i fail at all the tests I try.

They sent me death threats, and tried to hack my computer because I was a ”furry” (I don’t draw like animals with boobs, I draw stuff like pokemon) i have stalkers, whatever i do is always monitored…if i say something they didnt like they all came and tried to ban me from the sites I was on. They said all the stuff I had made was stolen, which it wasn’t, and they tried to ban me for that. one of my best friends backstabbed me, got everyone to spam me and send me threatening messages.

they called me retarded, they made fun of my mother, my name, they threaten to find out all of my personal information, to this day I get death threats for no reason, I was 10 when I first joined those forums and I was extremely new to the internet, the only point I threatened someone was when THEY threatened me, my mother found out about all the death threats againt me and she even wanted to call the police.

Now all my friends have forgotten about me, people I don’t even know hate me for no reason, my mom came into my room and had me delete my youtube account. My old friends made journals back on deviantart that a good friend had left, and everyone just seems happy that I am gone.

I made gifts for everyone, the site I was really popular on, I was hacked by those people and now they have ruined my reputation, making me look like a bad person, they don’t like me because i was smarter than them and told me i should get cancer and die, be ran over by a bus, i’ve tried to commit suicide and i was on strong anti depressants to stop myself from killing myself.

Every day I woke up, I just got entire sites against me, hate art, death threats, threats they would come and kill my mom…i mean i made gifts for people, helped people out if they had a problem, i was a very friendly person, and they took everything away from me and destroyed my confidence. ive told my mom and my teacher about the bullying ive been getting, now ive deleted my accounts on all the sites im on because nobody liked me anyway

I really feel like commiting self-harm because im so lonely and now im lonely on both ways, internet and real life. i never spammed, i never flamed a good person, i tried to ban the people who were threatening me, so did my parents but they kept coming back destroying me bit by bit. all i did was draw people art for them, post videos of me playing sonic, my virtual pets, zelda, talk on MSN, help people out and comfort them for their problems, I never did anything bad, but theyve destroyed my mind forever and i dont feel the same anymore

im so lonely now…
please tell me what i can do because i feel like im having a mental breakdown and i feel like im just worthless and dont deserve to live.

i get bulling in real life too.

, , , , , , ,

5 Comments